Winning Barbeque Sauces from Our Tasting Party

Winning Barbeque Sauces from Our Tasting Party

Grilling season is finally here and to a girl like me who grew up in Texas that means barbeque ribs, sausage, chicken and brisket dripping with a tangy, tomato-based barbeque sauce!  My mouth is already watering. 


But over the years I have learned that everyone has their favorite style of barbeque.  The varieties are endless.  Do you use a dry rub or a wet sauce, or both?  Is your favorite sauce tomato based or vinegar based?  Do you like it sweet, tangy or spicy?  Do you smoke or grill the meat?  The choices go on and on depending on family traditions and where you grew up.   Since our friends are from all over the country, we decided it would be fun to have a barbeque sauce tasting party to kick off the season and pick our favorites.  Links to the winning recipes are included below.

We started by inviting a few friends to bring their favorite store-bought or homemade sauce to enter into the taste tests.  No secret sauces were allowed because I told them the recipe for the winning homemade sauce would be posted on FoodieOasis!  After all, what good is a taste test if you don’t learn how to make the winning recipe?  They arrived on Saturday afternoon with sauces and lots of ribs!  We ended up with 5 sauces in the homemade category and 6 sauces in the store-bought category.


Now for the best part—tasting!  But to make sure no one automatically voted for their own sauce, I transferred the sauces to new bowls and added labels (letters for the homemade sauces and numbers for the store-bought versions).  Of course, I knew which was which so I couldn’t vote, but I still got to taste! 

Now for the rules.  We had small chunks of sausage, chicken, and bread ready for the tasting.  Everyone was asked to select their favorite sauce in the homemade category and their favorite sauce in the store-bought category. 

I have to say that everyone took this tasty task very seriously and many even did multiple tastings to make sure they knew how they wanted to vote.  It was not easy either because the sauces were really, really good.  But ultimately, the votes were in and the winners are:

Winning Homemade Sauce:  There was a two-way tie between

  • Karen’s sauce, our next-door neighbor with the great jambalaya that I wrote about in another post.  Click here for Karen’s Barbeque Sauce Recipe.
  • My sauce, which was based on the way I remember watching my mom make barbeque sauce when I was a kid growing up in Texas.  Click here for Jo Dale’s FoodieOasis Barbeque Sauce Recipe.

Winning Store-Bought Sauce

  • 1st Place:  Ott’s Barbeque Sauce, which our friends Jon and Will had shipped from Missouri just for the party because it was their all-time favorite sauce!  It turns out it was the group’s favorite store-bought sauce too! You can purchase it online here.  (Note that I have no connection with Ott’s, and this post was not sponsored by Ott’s or any other company.)
  • 2nd Place:  hak’s habanero pineapple bbq sauce, which was provided by Meredith and Eric.  It was amazing too.  You can purchase it online here.

With the tasting finished, it was time for everyone to slather their favorite sauce on the ribs and sausage!


But, of course, we couldn’t forget the sides, so we had some baked beans, corn on the cob, and warm German potato salad to kick off the grilling season.  I had requests for the baked beans (super easy) and German potato salad recipes, so watch for those in upcoming posts.




For those with a little room left for something sweet, Kelly brought delicious key lime pies with fresh raspberries.  I am certain everyone slept well after this feast! 

Happy Grilling Season!

© 2015 FoodieOasis





  1. Jo Dale, I cannot believe I stumbled on this blog. But I knew when I saw the name Jo Dale, it must be you! I am Tracy Robinson (Lane) we grew up together in MV. I love your blog. I will be trying some of your recipes. This barbeque sauce will be first. I’ve thought of you many times over the years. So glad to reconnect with you.

Leave a Reply